Yumtastic™ Cake Company

Customer reviews

Feedback from our valued customers...

"HUGE thanks to Andrea Bartucca and our friends at the Yumtastic Cake Company for this amazing JAF cake that almost looks too good to eat.

(Key word: *Almost* )"

-Joe Andruzzi Foundation

"Yumtastic made my son very happy today for his Birthday! Yes, it also tasted as good as it looked! A+ highly recommended and we will surely use them again for ANY cake needs. Amazing job!"

-Sam N

"We had a first birthday cake made. It was adorable and delicious! Will definitely be ordering again :)"

-Richelle S

"Andrea made the most amazing birthday cake for my son. Not only did it look awesome but it tasted phenomenal! We couldn't be happier! Thank you!! "

-Jen M.

"Andrea made a Moana cake for my daughters 2nd birthday which came out phenomenal! She was over the moon and it tasted just as fantastic!"

-Jennifer H

"They taste amazing as they look!! Can't say enough good things!! Don't go anywhere else for your cake!!!"

-Karyn B

"Great custom cake!! Red Ranger looked perfect. made my son's 5th bday! Easy to work with, reasonably priced!!! Very happy"

-Adam R

"For real! Best cakes of all time! We’ve had nothing but the best from them! Custom to the max and plus great tasting cakes and cupcakes!"

-Greg B

"Thank you so much for beautiful cake!!! Not only was gorgeous but it was delicious too!! It was so pretty that I honestly didn’t even want to cut into it."

-Marisa B

"We have had the best experience with Yumtastic Cakes!! Andrea always makes exactly what I ask for and the price is really reasonable. Thank you Andrea!!"

-Barrie D

"Coolest looking cake ever!!! Delicious too!!!"

-Sharon C

"I ordered a high end 2 tier carousel themed cake for my niece’s 1st birthday...and I wanted lots of detail!! I sent pics from Pinterest on how exactly I wanted it to look...and Andrea at Yumtastic exceeded my expectations!! It was gorgeous!! She is such pleasure to work with to, very responsive and friendly, and so talented!! Cake was such a hit at the party and bonus, cake was delicious!! I could never have afforded this cake at those expensive bakeries!! I am sold for life! Thank you Andrea for the incredible service!!"

-Kerri N

"We ordered a flamingo smash cake and matching cupcakes for our daughter's first birthday and were blown away with the quality of our cakes! The attention to detail, delicious flavor, and quite frankly, sheer perfection of the work had our guests in awe. Thank you!!"

-Siobhan K

"Haven’t dug into it year but the Brady (GOAT) cake that Andrea made looks awesome! I’m sure it’s going to taste great and my future in laws will LOVE it. Go Pats!!!!"

-Chris M

"Amazing cakes!! Not only look great but taste great too!!!"

-Tori B

"Andrea just made the best gluten free cake we have ever had! It was beautiful, but more importantly (for gluten free) it was delicious! We will be using her for all occasions from now on!!! Thank you!!!"

-Sarah K

"You nailed it! The cake was perfect, and everyone loved it! Can't thank you enough for helping to make Brianna's 13 extra special!"

-Erin F

"Beautiful, great tasting cakes. I highly recommend them!"

-Michael W

Learn More